Şahap Eraslan: The language that denies Kurdish Alevis — when victim becomes perpetrator
To say "there is no such thing as a Kurdish Alevi" is not merely to deny an identity. It is to force a person to choose between two parts of their own self.

RastinewsI am not an expert on Alevism. So I'd ask readers not to approach this piece as an expert's account.
Either give up your Alevism and stay Kurdish, or give up your Kurdishness and stay Alevi. Under the view imposed on you, you cannot be both Kurdish and Alevi. You have to choose one.
This is exactly where the state's language of denial shows itself: "If you don't give up part of yourself, I'll give up on you. I won't recognize you — I'll deny you exist." Those who insist, with real conviction, that there is no such thing as a Kurdish Alevi end up aligning themselves with the state, defending the theses of the state — of the perpetrator.
The Fallacy of the Unchanging Essence
I touched on this fallacy of the unchanging essence in an earlier piece, "A Mother's Feelings and Her Sanctity," published on Artı Gerçek on November 26, 2024. I wrote there: "What we imagine God placed inside women from the very first woman — what we call fıtrat, or innate nature — is really nothing more than a narrative, a legend." Every era expects something different of motherhood, yet every era treats its own expectation as women's innate nature.
We run into the same fallacy in debates over identity. Here, too, identity is assumed to be an unchanging essence, outside history and independent of human will — as if being Turkish, Kurdish or Arab were written into one's nature at the dawn of creation, fixed ever since Adam and Eve. As if peoples never changed over the course of history, never encountered one another, never mixed, never transformed their languages, beliefs and loyalties. On this view, a person has an ethnic, religious or cultural essence, and that essence stays the same through every historical change. Even when someone starts speaking another language, adopts another faith, or redefines their own identity, the claim goes, they haven't actually changed — they have simply drifted away from their true essence. A change in identity is read not as historical transformation but as alienation from one's essence. What's expected of a person isn't that they redefine themselves, but that they return to the essence they supposedly lost.
The biggest problem with this view is that it strips history of change. People change, societies change, languages, beliefs and cultures change. Yet it is claimed that beneath all this change lies an ethnic or religious essence that never changes at all. The transformations that actually happen across history are reduced to temporary layers draped over a supposedly immutable core.
This contradicts the dialectical understanding of becoming and change. In dialectical terms, a person is not simply a predetermined essence taking different shapes across history. A person forms and transforms together with the social relations they live in. Change is not something that happens to an unchanging essence from outside — it is built into historical existence itself. Historical and anthropological research on culture and identity likewise shows that ethnic and religious belonging forms, reproduces and transforms within social relations. It is difficult, then, to defend the claim that beneath all historical change lies some scientifically identifiable ethnic or religious essence that stays constant.
First an unchanging essence is invented; then serious debates follow over who that essence belongs to. The assumption underlying the debate itself is never questioned. In the end, an imagined essence is turned into an authority that rules on the identities of real people. Someone who says "there is no such thing as a Kurdish Alevi" talks as if the boundary they draw around Alevism had always been there. Even faced with a person who says "I am both Kurdish and Alevi," they don't doubt the boundary they've drawn. Instead, they ask that person to deny part of themselves in order to fit inside it.
A historically formed definition of identity thus turns into an authority deciding who people are. What real people actually live, how they define themselves, and which loyalties they embrace stop mattering. What matters instead is whether they fit a predetermined notion of identity. The idea of an unchanging essence, floated to explain people's identities, ends up justifying the stripping away of their right to define those identities themselves.
Identity Is Not a Fate
Identity forms, transforms and gets redefined within historical, social and cultural relations. People can change the names given to them, redefine their nationality and national belonging, abandon one faith or adopt another. They can live and define their gender identity in different ways. A person's identity is not a fate sealed forever at birth. A person is not merely the bearer of an identity assigned to them, but a subject who takes part in shaping their own identity. The freedom of identity includes the right to preserve, change, abandon and redefine one's identity, and to hold more than one loyalty at once. Just as it is domination for the state to force someone to give up their Kurdishness or their Alevism, it is also domination for a community to tell its own members, "You were born Kurdish, you must stay Kurdish," or "You were born Alevi, you must stay Alevi." The first tries to force identity to change; the second tries to forbid it from changing. Both deny a person any say over their own identity.
The freedom to preserve one's identity and the freedom to change it are two inseparable parts of the same right to be a subject. The view that treats identity as an unchanging essence strips a person of that right. It takes the authority to decide who is Turkish, who is Kurdish, who is Alevi away from the individual and hands it to some authority instead. Identity then stops being a way a person defines themselves and becomes a verdict others impose on them.
Essentialism and Fascism
The language that denies Kurdish Alevis: when victim becomes perpetratorThis ideology's relationship with fascist ideologies is not coincidental. Nazism's racial doctrine rested on the assumption that people possess unchanging, hereditary racial essences. Aryanness was constructed as a trait supposedly passed down through blood. There was no room for people to decide who they themselves were. A racist authority determined their identity for them.
Essentialist thinking can turn into a tool of fascistic domination the moment it denies people the right to define their own belonging and locks them into categories fixed by force. The phrase "there is no such thing as a Kurdish Alevi" goes beyond stating an opinion about historical origins. It is a claim to power over who gets to decide a person's identity.
Varieties of Alevism, and Encounters in the City
There is no single Alevism… There are Alevisms… And that can be seen either as richness or as a threat…
When we reduce the divisions among Alevis to a dispute between Kurdish Alevis and Turkish Alevis, we lose sight of the differences among Turkish Alevis themselves. Some describe Alevism as a faith and way of life native to Anatolia; others place Hazrat Ali and the Ehl-i Beyt, the Prophet's household, at its center. Both emphases can sit side by side in the same person, the same community. How is a cem conducted? How is the faith passed down? How is Alevism's relationship with Islam understood? The answers to these questions vary too.
Talking about a single Alevism is harder today. These differences existed before, too. In small, relatively closed circles, people could assume that the Alevism they lived was lived the same way everywhere. Someone growing up in a village near Maraş might assume that the cem was run in Çorum just as it was in their own village. They might even assume that people called Alevi in Syria had rituals similar to their own. Migration, urbanization and the ties built between countries have brought communities that once lived unaware of one another into more frequent contact.
Alevis from Çorum, Sivas and Maraş who met in Istanbul or Berlin may have thought they could build an Alevi association that reached beyond the borders of their villages — a shift from community to association. Associations and cemevis became the places where this encounter happened. Meeting face to face, they found that despite sharing the same name, they lived Alevism in different ways. A person had learned Alevism in the village. In the city, they discovered that what they had learned was only one way of living it.
From Community to Association — and Longing for Community
In his book Gemeinschaft und Gesellschaft, Ferdinand Tönnies distinguishes between two forms of relationship. In community (Gemeinschaft), people are bound to one another by deep ties through family, neighborhood and tradition. In a small setting like a village, relationships are dense. People know each other closely and need one another across most areas of daily life. In association (Gesellschaft), people relate to each other across a wider social sphere, through institutions, organizations, contracts and shared purposes. A wider field of choice opens up over who they will join and which communities they will belong to. In this sense, migration from village to city is a migration from community to association.
In a village where everyone is Alevi, if your parents are Alevi, you grow up Alevi too. No one asks you where you want to belong. You can live without ever asking yourself that question. Alevism cannot be separated from your family, your neighbors, your weddings, your funerals, your childhood. Seen from inside the community's own world, Alevism is the finest thing there is. There is little need to even wonder what a life outside that world might look like.
In Istanbul or Berlin, though, a child encounters other Alevisms, other faiths and unbelief alongside the Alevism learned from their family. They might live Alevism differently than their parents did, define themselves as an atheist while keeping Alevism as a cultural identity, or drift away from it altogether. The freedom to choose that parents gained in the city means their children can choose a path different from their own, too. In a setting where Alevism is a minority faith, some families who watch their own culture take up less and less space in their children's daily lives may see that possibility as a threat. How something learned through daily life in the village gets passed on to children in the city is now an open question. This is where the longing for community grows stronger. People miss the closeness of the village, and they miss the life in which that closeness passed culture on to children automatically. Cemevis and associations can become places where children learn Alevism by living it alongside other people. As people organize in the city through the tools of association, they try, within that organizing, to rebuild the deep bonds of community.
I think this longing plays a part behind the debates over Kurdish Alevism, Turkish Alevism, the emphasis on the Ehl-i Beyt, and Anatolian Alevism. In defending the Alevism they know, people also think about which Alevism they will pass on to their children, and with whom. Sometimes they turn to history to show that the Alevism they live is the oldest, the most authentic, even the superior one. "This is how it's done in our village" turns into "This is how it's done in Alevism." Then comes: "If you don't do it this way, you aren't Alevi." People who meet in the city to build an Alevi association can end up pulling back into their own separate communities. Belonging starts to be defined as much by who we exclude as by who we bond with.
The Repetition of Ritual, Belonging, and Folklorization…
To understand the longing for community, we need to look at how rituals repeat in daily life, and at the continuity of the relationships people build with one another.
In Sunni religious practice, the five daily prayers are built into the rhythm of the day, and the Ramadan fast into the rhythm of the year. Friday prayers, the tarawih prayers of Ramadan, and prayers performed in congregation bring people together at regular intervals. This repetition isn't confined to worship alone. Greeting others in God's name, saying "Bismillah" before starting a task, carries the faith down into the smallest moments of daily life. A person feels they belong to that community anew, inside these behaviors they repeat together with others. Repeating a ritual isn't only about fulfilling a religious duty. It is also about reproducing belonging. By repeating the same behaviors as others, a person feels part of a shared world. Rituals don't just express belief; by creating shared time, encounters and experiences, they also help sustain social bonds.
Alevism has practices like the cem, the Twelve Imams fast kept during Muharram, and the Hızır fast. How and how often these are observed varies by family, region and community. In some villages, the dede would come in winter to lead the cem. This gathering, spaced far apart, carried heavy meaning for the community. In the time between two cems, people still lived in the same village, saw each other, shared in each other's joys and griefs. Even when the ritual itself was rare, the relationships that carried the bond were lived every day. In a village where everyone was Alevi, there was no need to remember one's belonging through a daily act of worship in order to be Alevi. Belonging was lived not only in rituals but in daily life itself.
In the city, these relationships change. The encounters that happened spontaneously in the village grow rarer, neighborly and kinship ties shift, and people drift apart from one another. The long gaps between rituals are felt more heavily as a result. The bond that already existed in the village now has to be rebuilt in the city. That is why people turn more to cemevis, associations, joint commemorations and cultural gatherings. By the folklorization of Alevism, I mean one side of this transformation. Practices that gained their meaning in the village through daily relationships and lived faith can turn, in the city, into cultural forms that are remembered, staged or watched on particular days.
A semah performed on stage can revive a shared memory. A folk song, a commemoration, a semah can bring people closer. But the bond formed by turning together within a cem is not the same experience as watching a semah performed on a stage. In one, people are participants in the ritual; in the other, they are mostly spectators at a cultural performance. That doesn't mean the staged semah is meaningless. On the contrary, it can help preserve cultural memory and pass it on to new generations. But there is a difference between remembering a shared culture and living a shared life. Whether the closeness created by these gatherings lasts depends on how much room people still make for each other's lives in between.
The views expressed here are the author's own; they may or may not coincide with the editorial line of Rastinews. Rastinews is a free platform open to differing views.
