SKIP TO CONTENT
ARTICLES8 MIN READ

Jan İlhan Kızılhan's letter to Bafel Talabani: "Kurdistan's neighbors don't need to destroy it — they just have to wait for us to divide ourselves"

16:15

Psychologist Prof. Dr. Jan İlhan Kızılhan has published an open letter to Patriotic Union of Kurdistan (PUK) leader Bafel Talabani. Kızılhan argues that Kurdish gains from Bakur to Rojava have "never been rolled back by tanks alone, but by agreements, promises and patience," and says he now fears the unity of the Kurdistan Region could be next.

SHARE
Jan İlhan Kızılhan's letter to Bafel Talabani: "Kurdistan's neighbors don't need to destroy it — they just have to wait for us to divide ourselves"

RastinewsProf. Dr. Jan İlhan Kızılhan, a psychologist who has spent years working with women and children who survived the Yazidi genocide, has intervened in the Kurdistan Region's two-year government crisis with a sharply worded letter. Its recipient: Bafel Talabani, son of Jalal Talabani and leader of the Patriotic Union of Kurdistan (PUK).

Kızılhan wrote that the party's own framing portrays Erbil and Sulaymaniyah as two separate administrations, two separate Kurdistans. He said he recognizes the party's right to boycott and object, but that this particular statement shook him deeply.

The letter's harshest passage comes near the end. Kızılhan set side by side the PKK's self-dissolution, the SDF's (Syrian Democratic Forces) integration into Damascus's state structures in August, and the now-disputed question of the Kurdistan Region's unity. "Neighboring powers don't need to destroy Kurdistan in Iraq," he wrote. "They just have to wait for us to divide ourselves."

Kızılhan's criticism isn't aimed at the PUK alone. He also addressed the Erbil administration, which has failed to form a government for two years: "Power that isn't shared breeds despair in others."

Full text of Kızılhan's letter, published by Rudaw:

"I am writing to you from Germany, far from Sulaymaniyah — though my mind and heart have been there for days. I am not writing this as a politician. I belong to no political party; I speak only for myself and my own conscience. I write as a scientist and psychologist who has spent more than 30 years working with victims of war, displacement and genocide. And I write as a Kurd who has sensed, these past few days, the return of an old fear I had hoped was gone for good."

"Perhaps I find the courage to write this letter because I knew your father, and because I believe you are someone willing to listen, even to words that are hard to hear."

"Two years after the election, the Kurdistan Region still has no new government. When parliament convened in early November, your party withdrew from the government and declared that it did not recognize this parliament. Let me be clear: I am not questioning your party's right to political objection and opposition. Objection, boycott and withdrawal are democratic tools. Using them doesn't mean abandoning democracy — it means exercising democratic rights. A party forced to watch two years pass with nothing happening has every right to make its voice heard, loudly and uncomfortably. What worried me was something else. What overshadowed this understandable grievance, and shook me to the core, was your statement that 'what they do there, within Erbil's borders, we will do here, within Sulaymaniyah's borders.' Those words paint a picture of Sulaymaniyah in the hands of one party and Erbil in the hands of another — two administrations, two realities, two Kurdistans. And this on a piece of land small enough to cover with your thumb on a world map."

"Let me explain why your words affected me so deeply. I first met your father, Mam Celal, nearly 30 years ago in Beirut, and later in London and in various places around the world. I was a young man then, full of questions, unsure of what to do with my life. Mam Celal was already a defining figure in Kurdish history. After a long conversation in London, he embraced me, kissed my cheek, and told me to serve my people through my education and my research. He didn't speak to me the way a politician offers a few encouraging words to a young man — he spoke the way a father hands a son a responsibility. I never forgot that moment. That feeling stayed with me through my years of study, through my research, through the interviews I conducted with Yazidi women and children after the Shengal genocide, and through the nights when I didn't know how to put unbearable suffering into words. If I write about our people's trauma today, a piece of your father's embrace lives in every sentence I write."

"Mam Celal was one of the most important people in my life, and he still is — not because of the posts he held, but because of how he faced life's hardships. He could laugh at a time when people had been living through hardship for so long; he could speak to his rivals without compromising who he was, and he thought about future generations rather than election cycles. Above all, your father knew what division meant, because he had lived it and suffered it himself. In 1986, he reached out to Idris Barzani so Kurds could unite against the Baghdad regime. In 1998, he signed the Washington Agreement together with Masoud Barzani, helping end the Kurdish civil war. Your father later played a major role in merging the two administrations of Erbil and Sulaymaniyah. Nor did Mam Celal confine his thinking to the borders of Iraqi Kurdistan: in the early 1990s, he mediated between Turkish President Turgut Özal and Abdullah Öcalan, at a time when almost no one in Ankara dared even speak to Kurds. The idea Mam Celal put before the world in those days — that Turkey's Kurdish question should be resolved at the negotiating table, not with weapons — has remained alive to this day, through our era's peace processes. In this, Mam Celal showed something rare in our political culture: greatness lies not in insisting you're right, but in seeing the bigger picture even when you are."

"You may be asking yourself how a single sentence in a political dispute can trigger so much. The answer doesn't lie in day-to-day politics — it lies in a people's soul. Whether we were born in Sulaymaniyah or in London, we Kurds carry the weight of a history shaped across generations by oppression, loss and broken hope. Sheikh Said and Dersim; the Republic of Mahabad, not even allowed to survive a year; the 1975 Algiers Agreement, which Kurds still call a betrayal; Anfal and Halabja; Shengal and Kobani; Kirkuk and Afrin in October 2017. These names don't sit side by side like chapters in a history book. They sit like layers of rock pressed one on top of another — blending together, passed down from grandparents to parents, and from parents to children."

"A people who has seen its hopes shattered overnight, time and again, develops a particular state of alertness in which every tremor feels like an earthquake. This isn't hysteria, Mr. Talabani. It is the memory of a people who has learned that joy is, more often than not, followed by catastrophe. This wound has never fully healed within our people, and it has run deepest exactly where Kurd has faced Kurd. Whoever speaks today of separate administrations in Sulaymaniyah and Erbil reopens precisely this wound."

"I know the Kurdistan Region, within today's Iraq, is far from perfect. There is corruption, there are power struggles, there are injustices that need to be spoken about openly, and I have said so throughout my life. Even so, for millions of Kurds this region is far more than an administrative structure. It is proof that we can govern ourselves — proof that a Kurdish-speaking parliament can exist, that universities where Kurdish children can study their own history can exist, that a flag no one is imprisoned for can exist. In trauma treatment, there's a principle I rely on often: before touching the wounds of someone who has suffered severe trauma, we first build together a safe space, an inner refuge they can retreat to when the memories become too heavy. Without that safe space, healing is impossible. For an entire people, the Kurdistan Region has become that safe harbor. Kurdish children and young people in Berlin, in Washington, and also in Qamishli, Amed and Mahabad look toward this region. It is there that they find the answer to the question: can Kurds have a future that isn't only flight and suffering? Anyone who puts this region at risk destroys the safe harbor of a wounded people. That is precisely why this region must be protected — even where you and your party have suffered injustice along the way. This isn't about one person or one party. It is about the hope of forty million Kurds."

"That hope has shrunk further this year, and there is something that has worried me for months that I need to share with you. I am not someone who looks for a conspiracy behind every event. As a scientist, I don't trust simple explanations. And as a psychologist, I know how powerfully experiences of persecution and betrayal shape the way we perceive new threats. But I cannot look away from what has happened recently. In Turkey, the PKK announced its self-dissolution, and many of us, myself included, welcomed this as a necessary and correct step, hoping that politics could finally replace weapons. Earlier this year, Rojava came under heavy military pressure. In August, the Syrian Democratic Forces were dissolved as an independent military force and integrated into the structures of the Syrian state; the future of Kurdish self-rule there remains uncertain. This political experiment, which so many young Kurds around the world had watched with hope, has lost its old form, and what will remain of its gains is unknown. Now, only a few weeks later, the unity of the Kurdistan Region — the one place where Kurds have achieved a meaningful degree of self-rule — has itself become a matter of dispute. Each of these events has its own history and its own specific cause. But when I place them side by side, I fear a larger picture emerges: the Kurdish gains of the last decade are being rolled back one after another — and not always by tanks, but by agreements, promises and patience. I don't know whether this picture reflects a deliberate plan. Pictures aren't always planned. But those who refuse to take them seriously will one day be caught by surprise."

"I also know how difficult politics in the Middle East is. I have worked in this region long enough not to be naive; I am aware of the pressure from Baghdad, Tehran, Ankara and Damascus. This pressure weighs on you, and on everyone who carries responsibility in Kurdistan. But history has taught us a bitter lesson we must not forget: the states around us differ ideologically from one another, distrust one another, fight one another and seek different alliances. Yet the idea of a strong Kurdish society with the political right to determine its own fate has always been rejected by these capitals, however different their interests. The governments of these countries make many promises, and they can offer concessions to the political leaders of all sides. Precisely for this reason, we must not tie our future to the promises of these capitals. We must represent and protect our people's interests ourselves. Neighboring powers don't need to destroy Kurdistan in Iraq — they just have to wait for us to divide ourselves."

"Mam Celal left all of us a national legacy, and he passed on to you and your brother, Qubad, the particular responsibility of upholding it. I know this legacy is a heavy burden. The children of great men carry a double weight: a people's expectations, and the shadow of a name against which every step they take is measured. That is never easy, and sometimes it isn't fair. At the New Year, Qubad Talabani reminded us that we need to learn from the old conflicts that have damaged the Kurds' standing. He was right, and that understanding shouldn't remain just a New Year's message. You have every right to defend yourself, by democratic means, against the Kurdistan Democratic Party (KDP) and other Kurdistani parties. I am not asking you to stay silent or to accept injustice. I am only asking you to think about what your words create in us: in the Halabja victims still living with the memory of the 1988 chemical attack; in the students in Duhok and Sulaymaniyah who ask themselves each evening whether they should stay in these cities or leave; in that young Kurd in Germany who proudly tells friends about a country that almost exists. You are not alone, Mr. Talabani — but our expectations of you are great, because we know where you come from."

"These lines aren't only for you. They are also for those who govern in Erbil and hold power there. Failing to form a government for two years is not a sign of strength. Power that isn't shared breeds despair in others, and despair always finds a way out. Those who govern bear no less responsibility than those who object — if anything, they bear more. The KDP, too, should ask itself what effect its decisions have had on this people's heart, and whether it is ready to extend its own hand before others reach for Kurdistan."

"So debate the issues with your brothers in the KDP, argue with them. Compete in parliament, in the media, in the streets and at the negotiating table; fight for what you believe is fair. That is part of democracy, and a democracy without conflict or debate is no democracy at all. But this conflict must never harm Kurdistan. It doesn't matter who wants to harm Kurdistan — whether from inside or outside — no Kurdish politician should become an instrument of that harm."

"The overwhelming majority of Kurds, in Kurdistan and in the diaspora, do not want a new division. This letter isn't about who is right and who is wrong. It is about the survival of the Kurdistan Region, because it is our only hope. Mr. Talabani, can you imagine what I feel when I show my children the Kurdistan flag, and put my finger on Kurdistan on the map? Can you picture what it means for me not to have to tell my children about a lost country, but instead to be able to point to a place — the Kurdistan Region — that truly exists? Can you imagine the storm inside a Kurd who comes to Erbil or Sulaymaniyah for the first time in their life, and sees and hears that everything is in Kurdish — the street signs, the voices in the market, the songs drifting from windows, the language of teachers and police officers? Many cry in those moments, but not out of sorrow. What we tell our children about Kurdistan, about resistance, courage and freedom, is not a bedtime story. For the first time in generations, it is a reality. Don't let our dreams be shattered. Even if not for us adults, who have already lost so much, don't let it happen for our children, and their children."

"These days, I often think of that embrace in London. A great man embraced a young man he barely knew, and placed on him a responsibility far greater than himself. That man was Mam Celal."

"He believed that a people who has already lost so much should not, in the end, lose itself. Kurdistan must endure. Kurdistan — in Sulaymaniyah and Erbil, in Qamishli and Amed, in Mahabad and Berlin — must remain a source of honor, pride and hope for our children. This is your father's legacy, and now it is yours."

"With respect, in memory of Mam Celal..."

Dr. Jan İlhan Kızılhan is a psychologist, author and publisher. He specializes in psychotraumatology, trauma, war and terrorism, as well as cross-cultural psychiatry, psychotherapy and migration.

SHARE

Comments

Write a comment

READ NEXT

    Jan İlhan Kızılhan's letter to Bafel Talabani: "Kurdistan's neighbors don't need to destroy it — they just have to wait for us to divide ourselves" — Rastinews